Microsoft’s Floor Duo: A software program evolution testimonial, however for who?

A few months in the past, when I discussed that my beloved Google Pixel 3a smartphones have been nearing the top of their three-year help cycle, I indicated that I’d be transitioning each of my mobile accounts (AT&T for private use, Verizon for work) to Pixel 4a (5G) smartphone successors. Whereas that is still the long-term plan, at the least for Verizon, my AT&T path has already taken at the least a brief diversion to one thing I’d talked about a month earlier (and likewise alluded to 2 months in the past), a first-generation (“OG,” for authentic era, to the Reddit crowd) Microsoft Floor Duo:

Mine’s a 256GB carrier-unlocked open field unit, in like-new situation, that I’d purchased from BuyDig on Christmas Eve (joyful holidays to me!) for $420. Whereas that may look like a bit of change at first look, take into account that the unique MSRP for this explicit mannequin in September 2020 (first cargo date, with preorders starting one month earlier; it had really been publicly previewed practically a 12 months earlier) was $1499, with the 128GB variant $100 cheaper at $1399. Model new items direct from Microsoft are actually promoting for $699 (128GB) and $749 (256GB), presumably to filter stock in favor of the Floor Duo 2 successor:

Right here’s how they stack up spec-wise, each in opposition to one another, my present Pixel 3a, the Pixel 4, and the Pixel 4a 5G:

	Pixel 3a	Pixel 4	Pixel 4a (5G)	Floor Duo	Floor Duo 2
Storage	64GB	64/128GB	128GB	128/256GB	128/256/512GB
DRAM	4GB	6GB	6GB	6GB	8GB
Dimension	5.96 x 2.76 x 0.32 in (151.3 x 70.1 x 8.2 mm)	5.79 x 2.71 x 0.32 in (147.1 x 68.8 x 8.2 mm)	6.06 x 2.91 x 0.32 in (153.9 x 74.0 x 8.2 mm)	7.36 x 5.72 x 0.19 in (186.9 x 145.2 x 4.8 mm) (unfolded), 3.67 x 5.72 x 0.399 in (93.3 x 145.2 x 9.9 mm) (folded)	7.26 x 5.72 x 0.22 in (184.5 x 145.2 x 5.5 mm) (unfolded), 3.63 x 5.72 x 0.43 in (92.1 x 145.2 x 11 mm) (folded)
Weight	5.19 oz (147 g)	5.71 oz (162 g)	5.93 oz (168.0 g)	8.8 oz (250 g)	10 oz (284 g)
Display screen	5.6″ OLED, 2220 x 1080 pixels (441 ppi)	5.7″ OLED, 2220 x 1080 pixels (441 ppi)	6.2” OLED, 2340 x 1080 pixels (416 PPI)	Twin 5.6” OLED, 1800 x 1350 pixels (401 PPI), mixed: 8.1” OLED; 2700 x 1800 pixels	Twin 5.8” OLED, 1892 x 1344 pixels (401 PPI), mixed: 8.3” OLED; 2688 x 1,892 pixels
SoC	Qualcomm Snapdragon 670	Qualcomm Snapdragon 855	Qualcomm Snapdragon 765G	Qualcomm Snapdragon 855	Qualcomm Snapdragon 888 5G
Battery capability	3000 mAh	2800 mAh	3885 mAh	3577 mAh	4449 mAh
Mobile information (most superior)	4G (LTE)	4G (LTE)	5G (sub-6)	4G (LTE)	5G (sub-6 and mmWave)

Let me be clear upfront: regardless of the added and enhanced capabilities that the Floor Duo’s dual-screen method affords, IMHO it wasn’t well worth the authentic $1499 price ticket. I’d even go thus far to say that the identical goes for its successor, regardless of the 2^nd-generation enhancements (extra superior CPU, extra system reminiscence, 5G mobile help, enhanced digicam, NFC help, Look Bar, 90 Hz show refresh fee, expanded Slim Pen help, and so forth.).

However at simply over $400, I figured it was well worth the funding to see if there was actuality behind the “foldable” hype. And surprisingly, the discounted Floor Duo grew to become my “day by day driver.”

The Floor Duo has one thing of a convoluted historical past. Initially, it was supposed to be the launch {hardware} for Microsoft’s Mission Andromeda, a dual-screen-centric working system successor to the ill-fated Home windows Cellular O/S. When Microsoft determined to shelve Home windows Cellular in favor of an embrace of Google’s cellular working system, the Floor Duo staff redirected its consideration to then-latest Android 10. One downside: Android didn’t but (or nonetheless, for that matter, apart from current betas) have any cognizance of dual-screen, dual-foreground-app or related configurations, an omission that’s been equally difficult for Samsung (the opposite notable present “foldable” Android smartphone provider). Thus far, each firms have as an alternative needed to develop their very own Android add-ons. Learn any of the launch opinions of the Floor Duo and also you’ll due to this fact encounter no scarcity of reward for the {hardware}, albeit coupled with withering criticism of the software program.

My resolution to buy a Floor Duo of my very own was pushed partially by value but additionally by timing: per prior public remark, Microsoft was poised to launch a big Android 11-based system software program improve, after having paused its public replace releases the previous few months whereas it internally pivoted away from additional Android 10 growth. That Android 11 improve ended up being just a few weeks late, which gave me an opportunity to first check out what early adopters had been coping with (nonetheless benefitting from round a 12 months’s price of updates since launch, thoughts you). The advantages of a dual-screen machine grew to become shortly obvious; listed here are simply two of the various improved situations I encountered:

• Launching 1Password (my password supervisor of alternative) in a single show whereas logging into a web site or app on one other (Android’s built-in password supervisor help stays hit-and-miss in my expertise), and
• Pondering a possible buy within the Amazon app (for instance) on one display whereas price-comparing it with different retailers in a browser window on the opposite

However they have been balanced in opposition to oft-frustrating hiccups. Typically, for instance, one or each shows refused to energy on—or to stay powered on—till I closed and reopened the hinge (and generally it took a number of tries). And rotating the handset both horizontally or vertically, if it produced the specified show rotation-and-switching conduct at all, typically occurred solely after unacceptably lengthy latency. In making an attempt to discern whether or not I used to be encountering bugs, CPU/graphics/and so forth. efficiency limitations, a dearth of system reminiscence, or a mix of those, I first dove into the reminiscence utilization display accessible after enabling Developer Choices:

Enabling this has persistently inferred no reminiscence “hunger,” regardless of that the Floor Duo 2 has additional bumped up the allocation to eight GBytes. I’ve due to this fact concluded that what I’d skilled was a mix of software program bugs and inefficiencies, compounded by a no-longer-leading edge processor; whereas the first-generation Floor Duo makes use of the identical SoC because the Pixel 4, take into account that within the former case it’s not solely driving a barely higher-res show, it’s driving two of them, every probably equivalent to a novel foreground utility.

I say “probably” as a result of there’s additionally the choice to have one utility span each shows. My outcomes right here have been blended, due partially to a present lack of dual-screen optimized functions and to continued use of an working system that’s equally non-dual-screen tailor-made. Take the Amazon Kindle app, for instance. If I maintain the opened telephone in panorama orientation, I get two simultaneous pages displayed, one per display, like a e-book. Rotate the telephone in portrait orientation, conversely, and I find yourself with just a few traces’ price of lacking textual content within the ”gutter” the place the hinge is situated, as a result of Android treats each shows as one massive one.

That every one mentioned, there have been notable enhancements since I began utilizing the Floor Duo, each with the late January Android 11 improve (thereby explaining my earlier “what I’d skilled” past-tense wording):

And (significantly) with the follow-on late February replace:

At this level, the Floor Duo is actually bug-free for me, albeit nonetheless a bit extra sluggish than I’d favor. And I’m hopeful that Microsoft will going-forward fulfill its earlier “three years of help” promise by bringing now-beta Android 12L (which Google is paradoxically rolling out in parallel with the Android 13 beta for normal units) to the platform (some of us have already unofficially accomplished so through hacks, the truth is, together with Home windows 11!), thereby standardizing Microsoft and Samsung’s presently proprietary dual-screen workarounds, within the course of eliminating “gutter” points, increasing the accessible suite of “launcher,” digicam and different apps, and so forth.

A couple of different observations in closing:

• Lengthy-time readers may discover it ironic that I’m utilizing such a big machine given my earlier grumbles about big-screen smartphone pocketability. The Floor Duo is definitely extra totable than you may suppose, because of its thinness when closed, though it’s nonetheless not able to being safely squeezed into the entrance pocket of a cosy pair of blue denims.
• That mentioned, it’s a bit wonky when held as much as the pinnacle for conventional telephone operation. I’ve due to this fact been testing a collection of Bluetooth earbuds, the outcomes of that are scheduled to seem in a coming-soon follow-on writeup.
• I’m not terribly keen on the Floor Duo’s off-white colour scheme; the Floor Duo 2 optionally is available in black. That mentioned, it’s nothing {that a} pores and skin received’t repair (I’ve additionally invested in each Ice Blue and Graphite protecting “bumpers” to complement the Glacier one which got here with the Floor Duo).
• I’d initially deliberate on utilizing the Floor Duo with my Verizon account, however I used to be unable to get both Visible Voicemail or Verizon-to-Verizon textual content messaging to work (though exchanging texts with different carriers’ clients labored tremendous). Each points ended up being associated to Microsoft’s resolution to not pursue CDMA certification on the Floor Duo; because of this, Verizon accounts have to be configured with the “CDMA-less” possibility, which wasn’t possible on my group work plan. The Floor Duo additionally doesn’t help Wi-Fi Calling when related to a Verizon account, and I’m not conscious of any workarounds for that (though the omission wouldn’t have affected me personally, as my spouse and I exploit a femtocell, which Verizon refers to as a “LTE Community Extender”). All conversely is ok on AT&T.

What are your ideas about foldable telephones typically and/or the Floor Duo particularly, each in an absolute sense and relying on how they’re priced? Let me know within the feedback!

—Brian Dipert is Editor-in-Chief of the Edge AI and Imaginative and prescient Alliance, and a Senior Analyst at BDTI and Editor-in-Chief of InsideDSP, the corporate’s on-line e-newsletter.

Associated Content material